Positive Thinking as a Toxin

Imagine that a shark has a fish literally inside its jaws, but cannot bite down. Prayer is like that. It is like a “toxin” that makes you “invisible” to coronavirus.  These are sermon illustrations that Joel Osteen, one of the most influential preachers in the country, broadcast in the midst of the pandemic.

I know this because last Sunday I channel-surfed all the televangelists available in my basic cable package while I drank my morning coffee. I wanted to know if  they were social distancing and what they were saying about the virus.  Most were airing reruns or refusing to distance; it was not always easy to tell.

Osteen was the most interesting. Broadcasting from the stage of an empty church, he came remarkably close to assuring listeners that his combination of Christian prayer and New Age positive thinking gives them immunity to the virus.

He stated, “You don’t have to be afraid of the virus, God has a shield around you.”  Also, “God can make you invisible to the virus.”

It was not all virus all the time—he spoke about jobs, families, and divine protection from an all-purpose “the enemy.” Probably he has legal deniability if people die because of his inspirational message. Nor would I say that his advice to cultivate a hopeful outlook is all wrong in all contexts—whether for staying healthy during a pandemic, flourishing in an everyday routine, or whatnot.

Still he started and ended with God protecting people from the virus.  The implication seemed 90 percent clear, with only 10 percent wiggle room for blaming possible attacks from “the enemy.”

If you think a sermon should have one unifying image, Osteen is not for you. This one featured God/prayer/positivity manifesting all this effects:  defending Osteen against murderers by making him invisible, defending the prophet Elijah against his enemies by blinding them, dovetailing with M.C. Hammer’s rap song “You Can’t Touch This,” defending listeners against smoke and bombs that cannot disturb them, and creating a “hedge of protection” behind which “all you have to do is stay in the secret place.”

The climax was a story, its imagery conflated with the others, about a sort of fish which a shark cannot eat (supposedly, who knows if this is true?) because it releases a toxin that freezes the shark’s jaw and literally makes it impossible to bite down. Osteen explained that prayer is like this toxin, allowing the fish to be fearless and carefree.

“Verbalizing your fears” does the opposite: “negative thought is like bait.”

Osteen’s sermons are tediously the same in logic, week after week—relentlessly chipper, individualistic, and vague.  This one did not break entirely with the formula.  Nevertheless this was the first time—out of a perhaps a dozen times checking in on him—that his rhetorical promises had such a high degree of specificity and concreteness in relation to the news cycle.

Presumably, by this same degree of concrete focus, his listeners are now more specifically tempted to risk their lives with“invisibility to coronavirus” as their defense.

Often I have argued that much self-styled “positive thinking” is toxic in practice. To hear this overtly promoted as a “toxin” that paralyzes someone, or walls someone off behind a hedge, to stop them from “verbalizing” legitimate fears strikes me as revealingly evocative. It might be amusing, if not for the grave implications of this application.

MBE standard notice: The time I spend on this blog is not in addition to a Twitter and FaceBook presence, but an alternative to it.  If you think anything here merits wider circulation, this will probably only happen if you circulate it.

6 thoughts on “Positive Thinking as a Toxin

  1. I recently read an article the discussed the problems with positive thinking that you might be interested in.

    It worries me when religious leaders suggest to their followers that faith can cure various ills, but especially so when those ills are contagious.


  2. Pingback: Speaking Hard Truths | MBE: Mark's blogging experiment

  3. Pingback: Injecting Bleach or Ingesting Beach—Inquiring Minds Want to Know | MBE: Mark's blogging experiment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s